Sleeping Pills Stop the Brain’s Cleaning System

Ambien vs Natural Sleep Programs

Guest Post:

Our bodies rely on their lymphatic system to drain excessive fluids and remove waste from tissues, feeding those back into the bloodstream. It’s a complex yet efficient cleaning mechanism that works in every organ except the brain. “When cells are active, they produce waste metabolites, which also happens in the brain. Since there are no lymphatic vessels in the brain, the question was what was it that cleaned the brain,” Natalie Hauglund, a neuroscientist at Oxford University who led a recent study on the brain-clearing mechanism, told Ars.

Earlier studies on mice discovered that the brain has a system that flushes its tissues with cerebrospinal fluid, which carries away waste products in a process called glymphatic clearance. Scientists noticed that this only happened during sleep, but it was unknown what about sleep initiated this cleaning process,” Hauglund explains.

Her study found that glymphatic clearance is mediated by a hormone called norepinephrine. It occurs almost exclusively during the NREM sleep phase but only works when sleep is natural. Anesthesia and sleeping pills shut this process down nearly completely.

Taking it slowly

Dr. Maiken Nedergaard, a Danish neuroscientist and coauthor of Hauglund’s paper, discovered the glymphatic system in the brain in 2013. Since then, numerous studies have been conducted to understand how it works, but most have one problem: they were conducted on anesthetized mice.

“What makes anesthesia useful is that you can have a very controlled setting,” Hauglund says.

Most brain imaging techniques require a subject, an animal or a human, to be still in mouse experiments, which meant immobilizing their heads so the research team could get clear scans. “But anesthesia also shuts down some of the mechanisms in the brain,” Hauglund argues.

However, looking into the brain of a mouse that runs around and wiggles during sleep wasn’t easy. The team pulled it off using flow fiber photometry, which imagines fluids tagged with fluorescent markers using a probe implanted in the brain. So, the mice got the optical fibers implanted in their brains. Once that was done, the team put fluorescent tags in the mice’s blood, cerebrospinal fluid, and the norepinephrine hormone. “Fluorescent molecules in the cerebrospinal fluid had one wavelength, blood had another wavelength, and norepinephrine had yet another wavelength,” HauHaglundys.

This way, her team could get a reasonably precise idea of brain fluid dynamics when mice were awake and asleep. The glymphatic system turned brain tissues into a slowly moving pump.

Pumping up

“Norepinephrine is released from a small area of the brain in the brain stem,” Hauglund says. “It is mainly known as a response to stressful situations. For example, you see norepinephrine levels increasing in fight or flight scenarios.” Its main effect is causing blood vessels to contract. Still, in more recent research, people found that norepinephrine is released in slow waves that roll over the brain roughly once a minute during sleep. This oscillatory norepinephrine release proved crucial to the operation of the glymphatic system.

“When we used the flow fiber photometry method to look into the brains of mice, we saw these slow waves of norepinephrine, but we also saw how it works synchronously with fluctuation in the blood volume,” Haglund says.

Every time the norepinephrine level went up, it caused the contraction of the blood vessels in the brain, and the blood volume went down. At the same time, the contraction increased the volume of the perivascular spaces around the blood vessels, which were immediately filled with the cerebrospinal fluid.

When the norepinephrine level went down, the process reversed: the blood vessels dilated, letting the blood in and pushing the cerebrospinal fluid out. “We found that norepinephrine worked a little bit like an orchestra conductor and makes the blood and cerebrospinal fluid move in synchrony in these slow waves,” Haglund says.

Because The study was designed to monitor this process in freely moving, undisturbed mice, the team learned precisely when all this was happening. When mice were awake, their norepinephrine levels were much higher but relatively steady. The team observed the opposite during the REM sleep phase when they were consistently low. The oscillatory behavior was present exclusively during the NREM sleep phase.

So, the team wanted to check how glymphatic clearance would work when they gave the mice zolpidem, a sleeping drug proven to increase NREM sleep time. Theoretically, zolpidem should have boosted brain-clearing, but it turned it off.

Non-sleeping pills

“When we looked at the mice after giving them zolpidem, we saw they all fell asleep quickly. That was expected—we take zolpidem because it makes it easier for us to sleep,” Hauglund says. “But then we saw those slow fluctuations in norepinephrine, blood volume, and cerebrospinal fluid almost completely stopped.”

Hauglund speculates it could be possible zolpidem induces a state very similar to sleep, but at the same time, it shuts down essential processes during sleep. While heavy zolpidem use has been associated with an increased risk of Alzheimer’s disease, it is not clear if this increased risk was there because the drug was inhibiting oscillatory norepinephrine release in the brain. To better examine how the glymphatic system works in humans,

“We know to understand this better,w we have the same wave-like fluid dynamics in the brain, so this could also drive the brain clearance in humans,” Hauglund told Ars. “Still, it’s tough to look at norepinephrine in the human brain because we need an invasive technique to get to the tissue.”

But she said norepinephrine levels in people can be estimated based on indirect clues. One is pupil dilation and contraction, which synchronize with the norepinephrine levels. Another clue may lie in microarousals—very brief, imperceivable awakenings that, Hauglund thinks, can be correlated with the brain-clearing mechanism. “I am currently interested in this phenomenon […]. We have no idea why microarousals exist or their function,” Hauglund says.

But the last step on her roadmap is making better sleeping pills. “We need sleeping drugs that don’t have this inhibitory effect on the norepinephrine waves. It will be essential if we can develop a sleeping pill that helps people sleep without simultaneously disrupting their sleep.

 

Photo of Jacek Krywko
Jacek Krywko is a freelance science and technology writer who covers space exploration, artificial intelligence research, computer science, and engineering wizardry.

All Articles

Insomnia Quiz

The insomnia quiz will allow us to better assess your condition, and how best to help you receive proper treatment for your insomnia.

Go to Top